Two disparate news items this weekend got me thinking. The main stream media is all abuzz with Chelsea Clinton’s wedding, even to the point of throwing the term royalty around. It is estimated that the wedding will cost $3-$5 million, although Sally Quinn of the Washington post puts the bill at closer to $1 million. The comparison was then made to the cost of Jenna Bush’s wedding, a mere $100,000. This became fodder for The Joy Behar Show. Comedian Judy Gold leaped at the opportunity to take a shot at Bush, “Yeah, well, if he could have found a way for us to pay for Jenna`s wedding, he would have done that, okay, he likes to spend other people`s money.” An interesting perspective on other people’s money that I will return to later.
The other news items was an article in The New York Times, by Bob Herbert titled “A Sin and a Shame,” lamenting that corporations are hording cash and not hiring people and it is all so unfair, in fact, sinful. This is while this government is spending huge amounts of money that someone will have to pay back, massive new programs like ObamaCare that we are still uncovering what that will cost, and enormous tax increases about to kick in on January 1 when the Bush tax cuts expire. Perhaps they are hording cash for a reason? Perhaps they are not hiring because they don’t know what any new employees will cost under these new programs, or for that matter what their existing employees are going to cost? Perhaps it is because the latest economic reports show GDP shrinking and if that continues why would you start hiring if your business is going to slow down with the rest of the economy?
We have two very divergent views of the economy today. One view is held by those who actually work in the private economy and the other view is held by those in the ivory towers of government, which brings me back to the weddings. I really don’t care what the Clintons or the Bushes spend on their daughter’s weddings. It’s their money. But perhaps it is instructive to look at where that money came from.
George Herbert Walker Bush, Jenna’s grandfather, was born into a successful family. His father was a banker and a Senator. But after getting out of the Army after WWII he went to Yale and upon graduation, moved away from that family and settled in Texas to start an oil company. He went into private business and put his own money at risk. What that means, to those who never took that chance, is you may be successful and make a lot of money, you may be successful and make a little money, you may fail and lose your money. Chances are greater that you will lose than win, but that is the American Dream. If you lose, you have to start over by trying to earn and save up what you lost to try again, if you have the guts and drive. Bush succeeded in forming Bush-Overby and later with Zapata Petroleum. He became President of Zapata for ten years and then Chairman for another two, before going into politics. By then he was a millionaire in his own right.
George Walker Bush, Jenna’s dad, attended public school in Midland, Texas, where his parents had settled. He went to private school after the family moved to Houston. He later attended Yale University and became the only president to get an MBA which he did, from Harvard. Like his father, he went into the oil business starting several independent oil exploration companies. He later bought a stake in the Texas Rangers baseball team for $800,000 and was instrumental in building the team’s attendance. He later sold his stake for $15 million. Then he went into politics.
The two Bushes know risk, know about taking chances and became millionaires on their own before going into politics. They also learned lessons about spending money and doing so prudently.
Bill Clinton went into politics almost immediately after getting his law degree. He was Attorney General and then Governor of Arkansas. As governor he had a governor’s mansion. He ran for president and upon winning traded in his governor’s mansion for the Executive Mansion, aka the White House. He had been on the government payroll and living in government provided housing almost his entire working life. The sweat of the people in who paid their taxes paid him. After leaving office, Mr. Clinton was able to write books about his experience and make speeches commanding six figures a pop. His wife did pretty much the same. They lived off the people and ended up very rich. They didn’t create a product or service, they didn’t create jobs, and they didn’t meet a payroll.
I can hear the screams from the left right now, “What do you mean he didn’t create a job or meet a payroll?” Try this test. If Bill Clinton’s opponent was elected rather than Bill Clinton, would there still be a government payroll and government jobs? If yes, Bill Clinton didn’t create them. If either of the Bushes didn’t create their companies would there be jobs at those companies or payrolls? No.
What about some other famous politicians who tell us what to do? Let’s look at Al Gore. Here is another individual that spent the bulk of his career in government. He was a member of Congress, a United States Senator, Vice President and presidential candidate. Today he is very rich. It is said he may become the first “green billionaire”. If he went into his current endeavors before a life in government, would the story be the same? Or is it because of his name, reputation, and connections that he made at the public trough, that he is wallowing in riches, and telling the rest of us to reduce our carbon footprint while his mansions consume ten times the energy of his neighbors?
Charlie Rangel spent most of his life in government. He rose through the ranks and now has a waterfront condominium in the Dominican Republic, writes the tax laws but does not observe them, and is a wealthy man. Conservatives don’t believe in rent control or rent stabilized apartments, but Charlie does. After all, how can poor and middle income people afford to live in places like Manhattan if greedy landlords have their way. So Charlie Rangel who makes $174,000 per year, plus his chairmanship pay, has not one, not two, not three, but four rent controlled apartments. Is he poor or middle class? No, he is the political class. He took three adjoining rent controlled apartments and had them joined together, while the fourth apartment served, illegally, as his campaign headquarters. What about the poor and blue collar workers who could live in Manhattan if three of your four rent controlled apartments weren’t being horded by you? Let them eat cake.
John Kerry is in the news for trying to avoid $500,000 in taxes on his new yacht. Here is another individual who spent his entire working life in government. He can tell the rest of us to pay more taxes while he garners favors spending our money. He is the richest man in the Senate but with prenuptial agreements with his wife he only lists personal assets of between $400,000 and $1.8 million and joint assets with his wife of $300,000 – $600,000. So how does he buy a $7 million yacht? I am not suggesting anything nefarious, it’s obvious his wife paid for it, but do you think he is in touch with someone trying to make a payroll in the private sector? You pay taxes; John Kerry has advisors to figure out how to avoid them.
So those evil corporations started by those evil men like George Herbert Walker Bush and George Walker Bush, know the value of a dollar. They know we are not out of the woods yet and so to protect the jobs that their companies still have they are not hiring but are building their rainy day funds. Perhaps Bob Herbert should ask why his employer is shedding jobs left and right. Perhaps this is his safe way of doing so, but on the other hand the New York Times is hardly hording cash. Its circulation is crashing because people like Bob Herbert are so out of touch with the rest of America; no one wants to read his rants any longer.
So perhaps Bill Clinton spends millions on Chelsea’s wedding because he didn’t learn the value of a dollar. He lived of the government for many years and then just held out a basket and it was miraculously filled with more money than he can count. George Bush spent $100,000 on a wedding because he knows how hard it is to earn a dollar. What we need is less of the political class telling us what to do, and then handing us the bill and more entrepreneurial Americans who risk their own money, watch it like hawks, create jobs and generate wealth that they then reinvest in America.
Best wishes to Chelsea and Marc.
