If I asked you a simple question, what government organization works well, what would you say? Let’s take a look at two government organizations and compare their effectiveness and motivation.
The Military
Whether you support our troops on the battlefield or want them to always stay home in their barracks, most Americans will say the military does a pretty good job. Why? That is, why are they effective, not just why do people think so? Well, they put a lot of investment in training and technology. They seem to have solved the problem of integration, being based on merit rather than racial prejudice. These are all important things, but I don’ t they get to the core of the issue. The key question is, what happens if they don’t do their job? They die…they die, the guy beside them dies, their buddies die, and depending on the size of the conflict, their families and country may eventually die. With that kind of motivation, race is not even secondary. If the guy next to me has got my back and I have his, I don’t care what color he or she is. We do it right, we live; we don’t, we die.
The K-12 Teacher
K-12 education comes under fire in this country, and rightly so, for failing to produce an educated workforce. In New York, for example we spend over $14,000 per student, per year on education, far above the national average of around $9,000. Are students in New York 50% smarter than the country in general? Hardly. Is the nation as a whole turning out well educated students? Sadly, no.
Our K-12 public schools are a government run monopoly. So what happens to a K-12 teacher if they fail to do their job? If they have been in the job long enough to get tenure, nothing. They will get a raise like everyone else. So what motivates them to turn out outstanding students? I’ll wait.
Let me be clear that I don’t want to lump all teachers together. They are many teachers who, by having what I suppose is a strong moral streak, do a great job because they want to teach. Okay, so let’s look at the teaching profession where there is a group that does their best because they get satisfaction from doing a good job. Now, some studies come out that say the way to improve results is smaller classroom size. The teachers’ unions get behind it and eventually push it through. So what does that mean? If you cut the size of the class in half, you double the number of classes. If you double the number of classes, you have to double the number of teachers and thus have to go deeper into the labor pool to find them. Before you took this step, we can probably assume that all the self-motivated teachers were already on the job. So the additional teachers are motivated by what?
Co -conspirators
That brings us back to the teachers’ unions. When government’s come under pressure to cut educational expenses, the airwaves are soon flooded with the heart wrenching commercials pleading to restore the funding “for the children’s sake.” What you don’t hear is the trailer that says, “This commercial paid for by the PTA,” or “This commercial paid for by the Association of Concerned Parents.” No, what you typically hear is, “This commercial paid for by the X Teacher’s union, Joe Blow, President.”
Who do the unions really represent…really? The students? or the teachers? They want the funds restored so that their membership is not hurt and their dues are not curtailed. If their true concern was for the students, why not support school vouchers and charter schools? They fight the former with a vengeance and the latter, if it is not union organized.
Let’s Not Pick on K-12 Education
Let’s look at other government areas. Government is the only area where union membership is growing. How many people relish going to their Department of Motor Vehicles? How efficient is the Post Office? Amtrak? Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have a bonus compensation plan, which is a step in the right direction unless it leads to cooking the books and making extremely risky loans that lead to the near collapse of our economy. How can we get this under control?
Controlling the Uncontrollable
Our government is trying to install a massive health care program that will cost a trillion dollars. At the same time, tens of billions of dollars are stolen from Medicare every year and they can’t stop it. Early this year, the Obama Administration passed a $787 billion stimulus package, spent $18 million to build a website to track it, and put Joe Biden in the role of watch dog. How is that working out? A recent report from ABC News, of all places, found that credit for creating jobs was given on the web site to Congressional Districts that do not exist. A $1,000 grant was purported to have created 50 jobs. The New York Times investigated and found that the $1,000 went to purchase a lawn mower. It took from the time of the founding of the Republic until about the mid 1990s to accumulate $6 trillion in debt. It has doubled since then, and it is projected to go from $12 trillion to $14 trillion by next year!
It cannot be controlled. It is impossible to control. The only solution is to cut the federal government down to size. Take out the Constitution and read what the true functions of government are supposed to be. The military, absolutely; the Post Office, yes it’s in there; coin money; establish patents and copyrights; establish the courts; control the District of Columbia; regulate interstate commerce; make treaties; give the State of the Union address. That pretty much sums it up and everything else should be left to the states and local government or the people.
We should jettison all the rest and cut this government down to size and get out of debt. Department of Labor–gone; Department of Health and Human Services–gone; Department ment of Housing and Urban Development–gone; Department of Transportation–gone; Department of Energy–gone; Depatrment of Education–gone; Department of Veterans Affairs–gone, rolled into the Department of Defense; Department of Homeland Security–gone, rolled into the Department of Defense; Department of the Interior–gone; Department of Agriculture–gone.
The amount of money saved would be enormous. Selling all the real estate and buildings would bring in more money. We could then cut taxes to jump start the economy and run a surplus to cut the debt. The next step would be to make it illegal for unions to organize government workers without a referendum approved by all the voters. Side benefits would be less campaign money because there would be less government to influence. Government would be more accountable to the people because it would be closer to the people, that is, at the state level or local level. We can do this proactively, or wait until the government is bankrupt and we have to sell off the parts to the Chinese.
